In a world flooded with bestsellers and celebrity-endorsed titles, these 10 underrated books deliver powerful storytelling, emotional depth, and originality without the marketing buzz. Discover hidden gems that deserve a spot on your shelf.
1. NIGHT OF THE MANNEQUINS – S.G. JOHNS
A masterclass in minimalist horror, this novella from Jones takes a bizarre premise and turns it into a psychological spiral. What starts as a prank involving a department store mannequin evolves into a chilling exploration of guilt, delusion, and trauma. At just over 100 pages, it punches far above its weight.
2. THE PAPER MENAGERIE – KEN LIU
Ken Liu’s collection blends science fiction, fantasy, and Chinese mythology into heart-wrenching tales that linger. The titular story, “The Paper Menagerie,” is a Hugo, Nebula, and World Fantasy Award winner—and it’s just one of many powerful pieces in this criminally underrated anthology.
3. THE LONELY CITY – OLIVIA LAING
This is not just a book about being alone—it’s an artistic and intellectual meditation on loneliness through the lives of iconic artists like Andy Warhol and Edward Hopper. Laing’s prose is both poetic and analytical, blending memoir, biography, and cultural criticism in a way few books do.
4. THE INHERITANCE OF LOSS – KIRAN DESAI
Despite winning the Booker Prize, Desai’s novel never received the mainstream love it deserved. Set in the Himalayas during political unrest, it weaves together themes of colonial legacy, identity, and displacement with deeply humane storytelling.
5. THE PISCES – MELISSA BRODER
A poetic, raw, and weirdly erotic novel about heartbreak and desire—with a merman. Broder dives into the psyche of a woman spiraling after a breakup, blending fantasy with painful realism. It’s not for everyone, but for the right reader, it’s transformative.
6. OPEN WATER – CALEB NELSON
This slim novel is a meditation on Black love, masculinity, vulnerability, and art in contemporary London. Written in the second person, its lyrical rhythm makes it feel more like a long poem than a novel, and its emotional honesty is breathtaking.
7. THE HEAVENS – SANDRA NEWMAN
Time travel, alternate realities, and a woman who dreams of another life in Shakespearean England. Newman blends literary fiction and speculative elements to deliver a haunting narrative about fate, madness, and the fragility of utopia.
8. THE ILLNESS LESSON – CLARE BEAMS
Set in a 19th-century girls’ school, this novel tackles female hysteria, institutional control, and resistance through speculative and feminist lenses. Beams’ prose is elegant and tense, making this a quietly powerful and unsettling read.
9. THE BEAR – ANDREW KRIVAK
A father and daughter are the last two humans on Earth, living in a post-apocalyptic wilderness. Part parable, part survival story, Krivak’s quiet, meditative prose explores loss, solitude, and humanity’s place in nature. It’s a modern fable for a fractured world.
10. MADE TO MARKET – ELISSA SUSSMAN
Made to Market is a refreshingly smart rom-com set in the high-stakes world of branding and book publishing. Following a marketing executive and a reclusive author forced into a promotional tour, the novel blends wit, slow-burn romance, and a sharp take on the commodification of creativity. With whip-smart dialogue and emotional depth, it’s a perfect read for anyone who loves behind-the-scenes publishing drama with a side of chemistry. Sussman deftly explores how personal stories get packaged for public consumption—and what’s lost (or found) in the process.
LET THE HIDDEN STARS SHINE
The beauty of reading lies not just following the hype but in discovering stories that speak to us in unexpected ways. These underrated titles may not have dominated bestseller charts or viral reels, but each offers something rare – depth, daring and a voice all its own. If you’re tired of the same old lists and eager for a richer reading experience, let these hidden gems guide your next literary adventure.
Read More : 15 Underrated Novels you shouldn’t miss in 2025
