Book Summary
Set on the quiet yet curious Little Crescent Island, the story revolves around Alice Scott, a passionate journalist who lands an unexpected opportunity: helping the reclusive heiress, Margaret Ives, write her memoir. The catch? Alice is not the only one in the running. She must share the assignment, and her living space, with her professional rival, Jayden Anderson. Only one of them will walk away with the job, and Margaret gives them a month to prove who’s worthy.
What begins as a tense competition soon turns into a slow unraveling of personal truths. From Margaret’s tangled family history to Alice’s own struggles with grief and purpose, this novel is a journey through love in its many forms: romantic, familial, and self-discovery. Emily Henry weaves a touching tale of what it means to live, to love, and to write your own ending, even when life doesn’t go as planned.
Character Dynamics
- Alice Scott– An emotionally intelligent, curious, and thoughtful writer who brings empathy and depth to her interviews. Alice is navigating her own emotional wounds, especially relating to her parents and past regrets. Her passion for storytelling makes her the perfect lens through which readers explore the memoir she’s helping craft.
- Jayden Anderson– Charismatic, competitive, and unexpectedly kind beneath his confident exterior. His chemistry with Alice starts with intellectual sparring and slowly shifts into warmth, flirtation, and ultimately connection.
- Margaret Ives– The eccentric and guarded heiress hiding layers of pain, nostalgia, and lost love. As the book unfolds, Margaret becomes much more than just a subject of a memoir, she is the emotional thread tying the story’s past and present together. Her love story, full of secrets, heartbreak, and resilience, parallels Alice’s in subtle but moving ways.
Together, these three drive the emotional arc of the novel: Margaret guiding Alice and Jayden into uncovering her truth, while both journalists uncover truths within themselves too.
Favorite Tropes
- Enemies to Lovers– Alice and Jayden are rivals, both skilled writers fighting for the same gig. But as walls drop, their shared passion for stories, and each other, grows into something neither expected.
- Forced Proximity– Sharing space on the island creates intimate, tender, and humorous moments that allow their relationship to deepen organically.
- Memoir within a Novel– Margaret’s story adds a rich historical layer, filled with drama, heartbreak, and introspection. It’s as compelling as the central romance.
- Dual Timelines– Flashbacks to Margaret’s past blend seamlessly with the present narrative, giving the story emotional and historical weight.
- Soft Mystery– There’s a subtle air of mystery around what Margaret isn’t telling them. Piecing together the truth keeps readers invested until the final pages.
- Found Family– In addition to romance, the book highlights beautiful bonds between Alice and her parents, Alice and Margaret, and the way people who aren’t related by blood can become your truest family.
What Readers Are Saying
- Caz O’Sullivan (Australia)
“This book gave me huge TJR (Taylor Jenkins Reid) vibes, in the best way possible. I loved the memoir-style structure, the emotional depth, and the crazy Ives family dynamics. Alice and Jayden started off as enemies but grew into something much deeper. Margaret Ives? An icon. Her backstory was wild, emotional, and powerful. This one’s my favorite Emily Henry novel yet.” - ren itseli (United Kingdom)
“The romance between Hayden and Alice (note: some readers may refer to Jayden as Hayden) was absolutely swoon-worthy. But what stole my heart were the unexpected love stories, between sisters, parents, friends. I laughed, I cried, and I highlighted nearly every other line. It was a rich, heartwarming experience. Also, the twist ending made me cheer!” - Parul (India)
“I was a little disappointed. As a long-time Emily Henry fan, I felt this book lacked the emotional spark and romantic tension of her earlier work. The romance didn’t feel organic, and the plot was predictable for me as a writer. Still, Emily’s writing shines, even when the plot doesn’t land perfectly.”
What Stands Out
- Emily’s decision to blur the line between fiction and memoir creates an unusually intimate reading experience.
- The emotional weight doesn’t rely solely on romance; instead, it expands into themes of grief, purpose, legacy, and identity.
- The “mystery” surrounding Margaret’s life keeps the pages turning, even as the central romance simmers in the background.
- Multiple readers praised the journalistic lens and historical fiction elements, making this a crossover gem for both romance and contemporary fiction lovers.
About the Author – Emily Henry
Emily Henry is the queen of heartfelt fiction with a romantic soul. Her bestselling books, including Beach Read, Book Lovers, and People We Meet on Vacation, have made her a household name in contemporary romance. But Great Big Beautiful Life shows her versatility, proving she can explore love not just through meet-cutes and banter, but through legacy, healing, and hard-earned connection.
Final Thoughts
Great Big Beautiful Life is not your typical Emily Henry book, and that’s what makes it special. It takes bold risks with narrative structure, pacing, and genre blending. While not every reader may connect with its slower burn or softer romantic moments, those who lean into its emotional depth and memoir-like storytelling will find a rich, meaningful experience.
It’s a reminder that life, like love, is rarely neat. It’s a “great big beautiful” mess of stories, regrets, secrets, and second chances.
Perfect for fans of Taylor Jenkins Reid, Jojo Moyes, and anyone who believes stories can save us.
Read more articles at The Review Universe
