Review : A Year of Drinking Whiskey: Two Old Geezers (and a Great Bartender) Sailing Down Whiskey River

What happens when two longtime friends discover that they own dozens of bottles of whiskey but barely know what they are drinking?

They decide to learn, one bottle at a time.

A Year of Drinking Whiskey: Two Old Geezers (and a Great Bartender) Sailing Down Whiskey River is the entertaining account of a whiskey exploration undertaken by Patrick Sanaghan and Tom Nicoletto, together with expert bartender Julius Facenda.

What begins with dusty bottles sitting on a home bar becomes a much bigger adventure: tasting 365 different whiskeys from around the world and learning how to understand, compare, and appreciate them along the way.

Rather than approaching whiskey from the perspective of professional experts or connoisseurs, the book presents the experience through the eyes of curious learners. That makes it particularly approachable for readers who are beginning their own whiskey journey.

Book Details

Book DetailsInformation
Book TitleA Year of Drinking Whiskey: Two Old Geezers (and a Great Bartender) Sailing Down Whiskey River
AuthorsPatrick Sanaghan, Tom Nicoletto, Julius Facenda
GenreWhiskey Guide, Tasting, Food & Beverage, Personal Journey
LanguageEnglish
Print Length224 pages
Publication Date13 March 2026
Book LinkAmazon India

From a Home Bar to 365 Whiskeys

The premise of the book is simple and relatable.

Patrick Sanaghan and Tom Nicoletto realized they had accumulated dozens of whiskey bottles but did not really know how to drink or evaluate them.

Instead of leaving the bottles untouched, they decided to turn their curiosity into a structured exploration.

The result became a three-year adventure involving 365 different whiskeys from around the world.

That journey forms the foundation of the book.

Learning Whiskey Without Being a Whiskey Snob

One of the defining characteristics of A Year of Drinking Whiskey is its accessibility.

The book is not written exclusively for experienced whiskey collectors or experts. It is aimed at curious beginners, casual drinkers, and anyone wondering where to begin.

The authors approach whiskey as learners themselves, making the process less intimidating.

Their message is straightforward: you do not need to be an expert to develop your own taste.

You simply need to be willing to explore.

Understanding How to Taste Whiskey

The book introduces readers to a practical approach to whiskey tasting.

Readers can learn to evaluate a whiskey through four basic elements:

  • Appearance
  • Nose
  • Palate
  • Finish

These elements provide a simple framework for paying attention to what is actually happening in the glass.

Instead of simply deciding whether a whiskey is “good” or “bad,” readers can begin identifying what they notice and why a particular bottle appeals to them.

Exploring Whiskeys From Around the World

The journey extends well beyond a single whiskey tradition.

The book explores differences among:

  • Irish whiskey
  • Scotch
  • American whiskey
  • Japanese whiskey
  • Whiskeys from other parts of the world

This international perspective allows readers to discover how different whiskey traditions produce different experiences.

For someone beginning to explore the category, the variety can also provide a useful starting point for identifying personal preferences.

Reviews of 365 Whiskeys

At the heart of the book are the authors’ experiences with 365 different whiskeys.

These reviews are described as honest and entertaining, reflecting the perspective of two curious drinkers rather than professional whiskey critics.

The reviews are accompanied by personal observations, surprises, and lessons from the tasting journey.

This makes the book more than a reference guide. It is also the story of the experience of discovering whiskey.

A Simple Grading System

With hundreds of whiskeys to compare, having a consistent way to evaluate them becomes useful.

The book introduces a simple grading system designed for everyday drinkers.

Rather than relying on complicated professional terminology, the approach helps readers make comparisons and develop their own preferences.

The goal is not to establish a universal ranking of whiskey.

It is to make the process of discovering what you personally enjoy easier.

Trust Your Own Taste

Perhaps the most important philosophy running through the book is the idea that your own taste matters.

The best whiskey does not necessarily have to be the most expensive or prestigious bottle.

It can simply be the whiskey you enjoy drinking.

This makes the book particularly approachable for beginners who may feel overwhelmed by expert opinions, awards, price tags, or complicated tasting terminology.

The authors encourage readers to explore without feeling pressured to agree with anyone else’s definition of what makes a whiskey worthwhile.

More Than a Whiskey Guide

Although whiskey is the central subject, A Year of Drinking Whiskey is also about curiosity and friendship.

Two friends turn an everyday collection of bottles into an extended learning experience. With Julius Facenda providing expert bartending knowledge, the journey combines personal discovery with practical guidance.

The result is a book that brings together:

  • Whiskey history
  • Tasting techniques
  • International whiskey traditions
  • Reviews and ratings
  • Personal stories
  • Friendship
  • Humor
  • Lessons from experimentation

The History and Evolution of Whiskey

The book also explores the history and evolution of whiskey, giving readers context for the drink they are tasting.

Understanding where whiskey traditions came from can make the tasting experience more meaningful.

Instead of viewing each bottle as an isolated product, readers can begin to understand the broader traditions and development behind different styles.

A Journey for Beginners and Enthusiasts

A Year of Drinking Whiskey can appeal to readers at different stages of their whiskey journey.

For beginners, it provides an accessible introduction to tasting and exploring different varieties.

For casual drinkers, it offers ideas for discovering new bottles.

For more experienced whiskey enthusiasts, the 365 tasting experiences provide another perspective on familiar and unfamiliar bottles.

Most importantly, the book does not demand that readers approach whiskey as experts.

It invites them to approach it with curiosity.

Final Thoughts

A Year of Drinking Whiskey: Two Old Geezers (and a Great Bartender) Sailing Down Whiskey River is ultimately about discovery.

What starts with two friends realizing they do not know much about the bottles sitting on their shelves becomes a three-year adventure involving 365 whiskeys from around the world.

Along the way, readers are introduced to whiskey history, tasting techniques, international styles, grading, reviews, and the importance of developing their own palate.

For readers looking for an approachable whiskey book, beginner’s guide to whiskey tasting, whiskey reviews, international whiskey exploration, or an entertaining personal journey through the world of whiskey, this book offers an inviting place to start.

The philosophy is perhaps the simplest part of the journey: trust your own taste.

Scroll to Top